Lara Jean goes to the bookstore Josh works at to buy a book for English and to tell Josh that she and Peter are back together. Josh doesn’t express a big reaction to the news, surprising Lara Jean. Lara Jean’s goal is to convince Josh that she is not in love with him, but his lack of reaction to her relationship with Peter confuses her.

The family sits down for dinner, and their father gives them news from Margot. Lara Jean realizes that she’s only spoken to Margot twice since she’s been gone. Lara Jean understands that college must be busy, but she is disconcerted by the lack of communication. The family decides to send Margot a care package, a way of showing their love and support from so many miles away.

Kitty tells Lara Jean she wants a puppy for Christmas, and Lara Jean agrees to try to convince their father if Kitty can help out more and prove that she’s ready for the responsibility. The next day, Lara Jean is doing her homework when she gets a call from an unknown number. It’s Peter, telling her he’ll pick her up for school the next morning.