Back at home, Kit is relieved to know that Hannah has escaped to safety, but her happiness is short-lived. By noon, the Woods receive a visit from the constable, deacon, and the Cruffs. Goodwife Cruff produces the silver hornbook that Kit left for Prudence at Hannah’s cottage. It was discovered after the fire. Kit admits that the hornbook is hers and that she frequently visited Hannah, who has since disappeared without a trace. Goodwife Cruff accuses Kit of witchcraft, and the constable takes Kit into custody. Kit is locked in a cold shed until the magistrate can hear the case the following day. She has heard dreadful stories of past trials of witches and fears the worst.

The next morning, Kit is led to the town’s meeting house, where she is confronted by her accusers. Several villagers claim that she caused them to suffer various afflictions. Others believe she is responsible for the sickness that plagued the children of Wethersfield. To his credit, Kit’s uncle defends her and dismisses the accusations as nonsense.

The Cruffs come forward and present a copybook with Prudence’s name written on a page twice. Kit had used the paper earlier to teach Prudence how to write her own name.