Content Warning: This section of the guide includes descriptions of kidnapping and murder.

The narrative proceeds from Rachel’s perspective. “Rachel” is surprised when her captor appears at midday and commands her to follow him. He escorts her to the truck, reminding her that he is carrying his pistol. She tries to memorize landmarks and turns as they drive. In the center of town, he pulls over and greets the judge whose home he is renting. After saying goodbye, he tells her how kind and trusting the community is, and “Rachel” understands that he wants her to appreciate that he is thoroughly respected throughout the community.

The narrative briefly shows Emily’s perspective as she drives to Aidan’s house and sits outside in her car, ruminating on the idea that she should pursue him until she wears him down. Meanwhile, Aidan informs “Rachel” that he needs her to watch Cecilia during Christmas break while he is at work. He melts a reinforced GPS tracker onto “Rachel’s” wrist, but even with this added measure of security, she wonders why he would grant her such freedom of movement throughout house. She concludes that Cecilia must have done something to worry her father.