Oren urges Avery to drop her pursuit of the mystery of Toby, warning her “the repercussions could be deadly” (90), but she can’t. Avery continues researching the charities mentioned in the will. Colin’s Way is an after-school program founded in memory of Colin Anders Wright. Colin died in the Hawthorne Island fire, along with teens David Golding and Kaylie Rooney. Digging into old media clippings, Avery finds an old video of Colin’s uncle announcing the foundation of Colin’s Way: His name is Sheffield Grayson, and he looks exactly like Grayson.

Avery tells Jameson about Sheffield Grayson and her suspicions that the man is Grayson’s father. Jameson suggests they visit Skye in the luxury hotel she’s living in to ask her.

Jameson and Avery confront Skye in her hotel room. Skye confirms that Sheffield is Grayson’s biological father. Skye also reveals that she’s thinking of having another baby with her “friend,” Ricky.