Garrett and Wyatt exhibit open hostility toward Ryder during his stay for Christmas. Despite this, Ryder finds solace in bonding with Hannah while helping her cook Christmas dinner. During the gift-giving tradition on Christmas Eve, Ryder is taken aback when Hannah continues wrapping gifts late into the night, explaining it as a family tradition to have additional surprises for the children on Christmas morning. This gesture resonates with Ryder, deepening his appreciation for the familial atmosphere. As the night winds down, Hannah and Ryder drink whiskey together, and Hannah observes that Ryder is in love with Gigi.

Gigi initially plans for a quiet New Year’s Eve until her cousin Alex persuades her and Ryder to attend a party in Manhattan, offering a friend’s private jet for transportation. Despite some reluctance, Gigi convinces Ryder to join, highlighting Owen McKay’s presence as an incentive. At the party, they immerse themselves in the lively atmosphere, with even a hesitant Ryder dancing with supermodel Alex. As midnight approaches, Owen surprises them with his arrival, warmly greeting Ryder and revealing that Ryder is his brother.