As she recovers from her ordeal, Arabella reflects on Mr. Glanville’s intentions toward her. In a conversation with Lucy, she is shocked that he did not “strike his Bosom with the Vehemence of his Grief” when he learned that she was missing (109). When Miss Glanville visits her bedside, Arabella asks about her history, which she believes must be filled with romances and adventures. Miss Glanville mocks Arabella, and Mr. Glanville is concerned. He continues to act as Arabella insists, proclaiming his innocence and asking not to be banished again. When she banishes him anyway, he silently curses her romance novels. However, he finds that he still loves her.

During this time, Sir George sends frequent letters to inquire about Arabella’s health. Miss Glanville hopes to redirect his attention toward herself. When he does see Arabella, Sir George uses his knowledge of romance novels to say exactly what Arabella wishes to hear. She insists that Sir George must understand her life story, so she calls for Lucy to recite it for him. Miss Glanville assures Sir George that he will find the recital “sufficient to laugh at” (120).