After Arianna chats with Noah on the phone, she runs into Chase. He asks if they can talk. Arianna insists that they don’t have to go over what happened again and that she wants to let the situation go. After she leaves, Chase texts, saying that he doesn’t want to forget what happened between them. Confused, Arianna ignores the text.

Arianna’s family hosts Thanksgiving. All her friends come, including Noah. On their first night home, Payton goes into labor. They return from the hospital the next day, shocked that Noah has cooked them dinner. Afterward, Arianna steps outside for some air. Chase confronts her, insisting that he wants to be with her. He’s drunk and grabs Arianna’s arm; he won’t let go when she tells him to leave her alone. Noah appears and tells Chase to give Arianna space. Chase storms off, furious. Noah tells Arianna that she can go after him if she wants to. Arianna feels confused, but she goes to find Chase. He again tells her that he wants to be with her even though he didn’t before. He kisses her, and she pulls away. She accuses Chase of being unfair because she’s with Noah. She races back to the house and finds Noah, telling him what happened.