15 pages 30 minutes read

Jane Kenyon

Otherwise

Fiction | Poem | Adult | Published in 1996

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Poem Analysis

Analysis: “Otherwise”

The poem begins with an image of the speaker’s physical strength: “I got out of bed / on two strong legs” (Lines 1-2). This image suggests an effortless rising and implies that the speaker sees themselves as able to pull themselves up. The first mention of a contrasting refrain that runs throughout the poem, “It might have been/otherwise” (Lines 3-4), undercuts the confident start to the day. This hint of impermanence or inevitable change gives the reader a glimpse into the undercurrent of potential physical weakness in the future.

The speaker describes their current task of eating breakfast. Though meals can be a rote chore, the speaker pays deep attention to the “cereal” (Line 5) they eat, the “sweet / milk” (Lines 6-7), and a “ripe, flawless / peach” (Line 6-7). Again, the refrain “It might / have been otherwise” (Lines 7-8), undercuts this vivid moment, hinting that eating may not always be an accessible pleasure, giving the refrain an ominous quality. The third image of the poem describes another domestic task: “I took the dog uphill / to the birch wood” (Lines 9-10). These lines echo the image of physical strength at the start of the poem when the speaker gets out of bed.

Related Titles

By Jane Kenyon

Study Guide

logo

Having It Out with Melancholy

Jane Kenyon

Having It Out with Melancholy

Jane Kenyon

Study Guide

logo

Let Evening Come

Jane Kenyon

Let Evening Come

Jane Kenyon

Study Guide

logo

The Blue Bowl

Jane Kenyon

The Blue Bowl

Jane Kenyon