Huguet and her family are under immense emotional as they await justice, dealing with multiple postponements of Donaldson’s hearing. Missoula County Attorney Fred Van Valkenburg struggles with last-minute preparations, and key witness Hillary McLaughlin wavers on whether to testify, grappling with the trauma of her own assault by Donaldson. When the hearing occurs, the courtroom is tense, filled with supporters of both Donaldson and Huguet. Kevin Huguet, Allison’s father, gives a powerful testimony, expressing his anger and despair over the impact of Donaldson’s crime on his family. Keely Williams, Huguet’s friend, provides crucial testimony about the night of the rape and the toll it took on Huguet’s life.

During the sentencing hearing of Donaldson, Huguet testifies that she and Donaldson never had a romantic relationship. She also recounts the traumatic details of the rape, including her fear and the lasting psychological impact. She reflects on her emotional turmoil upon encountering Donaldson after the assault; she realized he showed no remorse and worried that her silence might have enabled him to harm others. Despite her conflicted feelings due to their past friendship, Huguet emphasizes her belief that Donaldson should be punished and hopes that he eventually understands the gravity of his actions.