Tobin doesn’t appear at breakfast, and Lemonade is nervous. She puts on her official badge and props Rainbow up on her pillow before heading to headquarters, where Tobin is on the phone with Mrs. Dickerson, telling her that he no longer believes her sightings. When she reveals that she has a Polaroid, Tobin decides to investigate. Lemonade asks if he’s mad at her, but he says no. Before leaving, Lemonade notices another message on the machine. It’s from a classmate named Eliza, who claims to have seen a Bigfoot in the woods with her friends the night before. She asks for Lemonade, which makes Tobin suspicious.

After visiting Mrs. Dickerson, who has a picture of what seems like a Bigfoot eye, they head to Eliza’s, where they learn that a Bigfoot came out of the woods while Eliza was playing with her friends. Her father grabbed a rifle and was planning to shoot it if it attacked. Eliza mentions the kick the can game the day before, and Tobin glares at Lemonade. Lemonade comes across a clod of fur in the woods that appears to be from a Bigfoot.