The narrative shifts to Dave’s perspective in the aftermath of Mia’s confrontation. Dave feels guilty for not being honest with Mia and wishes that he could tell her the truth about his connection to Abigail and Precious. Thinking of Abigail and Precious prompts Dave to reflect on his childhood. Raised in an abusive and impoverished home, he was alternately bullied and neglected. At school, his classmates taunted him because of his undiagnosed dyslexia and a prominent birthmark on his face. Dave reflects that Abigail and Precious were kind to him, and he treasured that kindness because it was so rare. Despite these fond memories, Dave alerts Debbie that Mia has been asking questions about Abigail and Precious. Dave watches Debbie decide how best to deal with this development and warily backs away from her.

This chapter shifts to Finn’s perspective as Mia attempts to confide in him. She presents him with evidence that Dave has a suspicious connection to one of the murdered girls. Like Dave, Finn downplays her concerns. As he gaslights her and attempts to intimidate her into dropping her investigation, Finn tells himself that Mia is too good for him.