1. General Impressions 

 Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

• Did you see the final plot twist of the novel coming? What clues in the text led you to expect this twist?
• In Five Years blends the genres of romance and magical realism. How did you feel about this combination of genres? Were there any moments in the plot that you think blended these elements better or worse than others?
• Did you believe Dannie and Aaron would get together? Was there ever a moment that convinced you of this, or that Dannie would finally marry David?

2. Personal Reflection and Connection 

 Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

• Did you find Dannie or Bella more relatable? Did you like either character more at the end of the novel than at the start?
• Do you think you could have a platonic relationship with the love of your life? Do you have a relationship like the one between Dannie and Bella that leads you to your answer? 
• Have you ever put off a major decision because something about it didn’t feel right? If you were in Dannie’s position, would you have ended your relationship with David? 
• What did you feel when you read about Bella’s cancer diagnosis? Were you expecting something like this from a romance novel?
• Do you believe in found family? Why or why not?

3.