A week later, Willow asks Charity to leave work to get milkshakes. It’s a tradition they’ve had since they were kids: They share their problems over milkshakes and promise that they’ll be kept secret. While they enjoy their milkshakes, Willow tells Charity everything that happened with Cam.

Charity responds with shock, unable to believe that Willow doesn’t realize that Cam loves her and that he always has. Willow tries to argue, but Charity insists that she’s finally “ready” to hear that fact and deal with it.

Gid interrupts their conversation. He sits at their table and makes small talk, but Judge Bradley’s arrival interrupts them. As she sees how angry her father is, Willow realizes that Gid came to warn them of an impending confrontation.

Their father walks up to their table and accuses Willow of siding with Cam on the motion that he filed with his court. Willow tells him that she has no idea what he’s talking about, but her father insists that she has been seeing Cam since he came back into town. Willow tries to explain that she hasn’t seen him in a week, but her father angrily interrupts her. Gid stands and tries to calm Judge Bradley down, telling him to discuss the private matter later since the entire diner is watching them.