48 pages 1 hour read

Marie Benedict

Carnegie's Maid

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2018

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Living Quarters

The living quarters occupied by the novel’s characters are described in great detail because they symbolize the relative status of each individual and speak to the theme of The Class System. These distinctions are at play from the story’s earliest pages. Clara travels to America in steerage, or the cargo hold of the ship where passengers can’t even bathe and are barred from mingling above deck with the other passengers. When Clara gets into the coach with Mrs. Seeley’s other two hired girls, they are put off by Clara’s dirty, bedraggled appearance because they traveled in second class. The space in which one is allowed to live conveys one’s value—both in quality and amount.

When Clara takes up her residence in the Carnegie mansion, distinctions are still maintained. Mrs. Carnegie’s opulent bedroom is contrasted with Clara’s own sparse accommodations. Although spartan, Clara’s bedroom is a palace compared to the filthy lean-to where her cousins live in Slab Town. Similarly, her family in Ireland loses their cozy cottage and must move into the deprived areas of Galway City. The living quarters are so wretched and the air quality so poor that Clara’s younger sister contracts a disease and dies there.

Related Titles

By Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

Lady Clementine

Marie Benedict

Lady Clementine

Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

The First Ladies

Marie Benedict, Victoria Christopher Murray

The First Ladies

Marie Benedict, Victoria Christopher Murray

Study Guide

logo

The Mitford Affair

Marie Benedict

The Mitford Affair

Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Marie Benedict

The Mystery of Mrs. Christie

Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

The Only Woman in the Room

Marie Benedict

The Only Woman in the Room

Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

The Other Einstein

Marie Benedict

The Other Einstein: A novel

Marie Benedict

Study Guide

logo

The Personal Librarian

Marie Benedict, Victoria Christopher Murray

The Personal Librarian

Marie Benedict, Victoria Christopher Murray