Anonymous

Anonymous (2013) is a thriller and psychological suspense novel by Christine Benedict. Based on a true story, the book centers on a woman who moves into an old farmhouse; her neighbor starts receiving disturbing letters from a nameless stalker, and together they must uncover the stalker’s identity before he gets violent. Anonymous was nominated for several awards including the 2015 Wishing Shelf Book Award and the 2015 IAN Horror/Suspense Book of the Year. Benedict studied creative writing at Baldwin Wallace University. Anonymous is her first novel. The letters included in the book are real—Benedict had her own stalker, who remains anonymous to this day.

The story takes place in America in 1984. Twenty-one-year-old Debra Hamilton is married to Greg, whom she married straight out of high school. Although she cares about Greg, she doesn’t think she loves him anymore. Still, she wants to make their marriage work.

Debra didn’t have an easy childhood. She grew up in the foster care system, eventually running away from her foster parents because they treated her badly. She wonders if she fell in love with Greg because he was the first man to ever show her genuine kindness. It doesn’t matter now, though, as Debra doesn’t plan to divorce him. She believes that family should stick together, whatever happens.



When the book opens, Greg is driving Debra to their new home out in the country, a century-old farmhouse set on a 53-acre plot of land that no one else wants to buy. Although it has 14 rooms and so much extra space, it’s a blacklisted property. Dilapidated and spooky, the locals think that it is haunted.

Debra doesn’t want to move in; the house gives her a bad vibe. Greg, however, bought it as a project. He can’t wait to renovate it, turning it into a perfect family home. Not wanting to upset him, Debra doesn’t tell Greg how bad the house makes her feel. She knows he is trying to make their marriage work, and the house will be perfect for them in the long run.

Although she tries to act supportive, Debra feels that the house doesn’t want her there. She hears strange noises, it’s freezing all the time, and she can’t sleep at night. The floorboards creak, everything is rusty and moldy, and carpenter ants live in the walls. If Greg notices how bad the house is, he doesn’t show it.



Debra is concerned about her own mental health. The state placed her in foster care because her mother had paranoid schizophrenia. Although she loved Debra, she couldn’t care for her properly. Debra worries that she has inherited her mother’s psychiatric illness. She doesn’t know if the house is haunted or if she is developing paranoid schizophrenia. She doesn’t talk to Greg about her concerns because she doesn’t want to worry him.

Debra decides to get out of the house to meet the locals. She first meets her neighbor, Julie Zourenger. Julie’s husband, Kyle, is nothing like Greg. Hotheaded and argumentative, he is extremely possessive of Julie. Julie doesn’t feel safe around Kyle, but she has nowhere else to go. She hopes that he will leave her one day and simply never come home.

The more Debra learns about Julie’s relationship with Kyle, the more she examines her own marriage. Although she doesn’t love Greg romantically anymore, she cares about him deeply. He’s her best friend, and she can’t imagine a life without him. Recognizing that her marriage is worth fighting for, she vows to do everything she can to protect it.



One day, Julie reveals a disturbing secret: She has been receiving twisted, perverted letters from an anonymous stalker. Calling himself “Smitten,” he sets out detailed sexual fantasies. The letters terrify Julie, but she doesn’t know how to stop them. Debra decides to help Julie uncover the stalker’s identity before the stalking escalates.

Meanwhile, Debra attracts the attention of the local game warden. He flirts with Debra, creeping her out. She assumes that he is “Smitten,” because he’s creepy and weird, but Julie isn’t so sure. She’s convinced that it’s somebody else. Debra doesn’t tell Greg about the game warden or “Smitten” because Julie asks her to keep it secret. Julie doesn’t want Kyle to find out because he will blame her.

Kyle eventually finds out about the letters and plans to take revenge. As Julie anticipated, Kyle blames her for the stalking. He claims that she is flirting with men and giving them the wrong idea. Debra doesn’t know what to do because she knows that Julie isn’t safe, but she doesn’t believe in meddling in someone else’s marriage.



Meanwhile, Debra’s mental health deteriorates. She sees things that aren’t there, and she is still not sure if a ghost is responsible or if she’s developing schizophrenia. She throws all her energy into finding out the stalker’s identity, who turns out the be the game warden. Greg realizes he’s neglecting Debra and he vows to spend more time working on their marriage rather than the house project.