Do you believe that we are “our brother’s keepers”? Explain in terms of Norman and his father’s beliefs. For example, does Norman’s responsibility extend to Neal? Why or why not? Who does Maclean, the author, believe to be our brothers?

Throughout the novella, the motif of the river symbolizes human life. How does this motif account for Paul’s death? What does it mean that he is a master fly fisherman? Explain his talents and problems in terms of the symbols of fly fishing and the river.

What are the similarities and differences between Norman and Jessie’s family situations? How do they handle the members of their families?